The short answer. The new year is right around the corner, and you are most likely running a Stars strategy built last spring. It was written before your newest Star Ratings came out, before you knew which bets paid off, and inside a budget cycle that only looks twelve months ahead. That is a budget, not a Stars strategy. A real strategy is a three-year plan with owners, budgets, resources, initiatives, and data, and it gets rearranged every time CMS moves the rules.
You are managing a rating you can no longer change
The Star Ratings you just received reflect care delivered two years ago for most measures. The work your teams do in the year that starts in a few weeks may not show up in a rating for another two years.
So when your board asks why the rating dropped, the honest answer is a decision someone made two years ago. And when they ask what you are doing about it, a one-year plan can only answer with activity.
The annual fire drill has a pattern
Most plan leaders will recognize it:
Budgets lock in July. Results land in October. The budget is set before anyone knows what needed fixing.
Vendor contracts renew because the renewal date arrives, not because anyone tested the results, evaluated vendor performance, or asked whether there is a better way to do the "thing" this year.
The first quarter goes to onboarding, HRAs, new data feeds, MRR, and making sure new members understand their benefits. The second quarter goes to HEDIS season. Real improvement work starts with half the measurement year already gone. Part of that is the data lag. But plans can do this differently now, especially if they have internal AI tools.
Care managers get pulled onto gap closure calls. The nurses who should be with your highest-risk members are dialing for screenings. That cost never shows up in the Stars budget. It shows up later in medical cost.
None of this is a talent problem. It is a calendar problem and a budget timing problem, and the calendar always wins unless you plan past it. Often, that is what drives the resource problem.
The rules will move, so plan for it
The CY 2027 Medicare Advantage and Part D final rule removed 11 measures, most of them administrative measures that plans generally performed well on. That boost is gone. It added a Depression Screening and Follow-Up measure that starts with measurement year 2027 and the 2029 Star Ratings. The 2027 Star Ratings also raised the Health Outcomes Survey improvement measures for physical and mental health from a weight of one to a weight of three.
Read the direction. The easy, inside-the-building points are leaving. What is left depends on providers, behavioral health, and how members feel about their care. None of that moves in one season. And the next round is already coming: CMS's contract year 2028 proposed rule is already under federal review.
Five questions that separate a roadmap from a wish list
Your leadership team should be able to answer these in one meeting. If it takes a month, you have a wish list.
Which measures are we betting on, and which are we deliberately not chasing?
For each bet, does the lever sit inside our building or in a provider's exam room?
Who owns each bet, and do they control the workflow, contract, or budget that moves it? Can you control it or does someone else?
What will we see by mid-2027 that tells us it is working?
What happens to the plan when CMS changes a measure next spring?
The questions are the easy part. Answering them honestly takes a measure-by-measure read of your contract, your data, and your provider network. It also takes the discipline to say no to work that will not pay off until 2030, even when someone is asking for a quick win.
Three years, not three quarters
A real roadmap works on three horizons at once: what you fix now that pays in the next measurement year, what you build through provider contracts and data that pays in two, and what you protect so last year's gains do not slip. Then you re-score it every spring, after CMS finalizes the next rule. A multi-year plan is not a static plan. It expects to be wrong in places and has a way to find out early.
If you are deciding right now which initiatives and vendors carry into measurement year 2027, start with Your 2027 Star Ratings are in. Now decide what strategy stays.
What to do next
Before you approve the 2027 budget, ask your Stars and Quality lead for written answers to the five questions above.
Split that budget into work with outcomes that can move the 2029 Star Ratings and work that only produces activity.
Count how many care management hours went to gap closure calls in 2026, and who they came from. Is this the right team to help with gap closure, or are they already busy managing members, controlling cost of care, preventing readmissions, and being the face of your MLR?
Put a roadmap re-score on the calendar for the week CMS releases its next final rule.
Stars rewards plans that decide early and hold the line long enough to see it pay. If your Stars plan has a fiscal year on the cover, it is time to talk.
Sources
CMS, 2027 Medicare Advantage and Part D Star Ratings fact sheet, October 8, 2026. cms.gov
CMS, "Contract Year 2027 Medicare Advantage and Part D Final Rule" fact sheet, April 2, 2026. cms.gov
Office of Information and Regulatory Affairs, pending review of the CMS Contract Year 2028 Medicare Advantage and Part D proposed rule (CMS-4214). reginfo.gov
About the author
Tina M. Dueringer, BSN, RN, CCM, PCC is CEO and Principal Advisor of Dueringer Advisors, Inc., a clinically led advisory firm for health plans and the companies that serve them. About Tina
Discuss this on LinkedIn: Join the conversation on LinkedIn
Talk with us: Contact Dueringer Advisors