Your 2027 Star Ratings are out. The next six weeks are when you decide which Stars initiatives and vendors earn another year, which ones go, and what is missing. Make those calls on the measures you have today. Do not pause your strategy waiting for a court to remove a measure. It may not happen, and it may take years if it does.
The calendar is not on your side
CMS released the 2027 Star Ratings on October 8, 2026. Most plans spent October reading their results and November defending budgets. Meanwhile, the next scoring window is about to open. CMS has said the 2029 Star Ratings will use measurement year 2027. Whatever you have not fixed by January 1, 2027 starts the year broken.
Keep, cut, fix, or add: four calls for every initiative
Put every Stars initiative and vendor on one list. Then make one of four calls for each. Here is how we think about each call.
Keep it when it improved the rate and you can show it at the member level. Activity in itself does not qualify. Calls made, letters sent, and gaps "touched" describe effort, not results. The test we use: look at the members who closed the gap. Would most of them have closed it anyway?
Cut it when it produced activity without movement, or when its measure is leaving the program through rulemaking.
Fix it when the idea was right and the execution was not. The usual causes are the wrong owner, the wrong timing, or the wrong data. A provider program that launched in the third quarter got half a year to work. A gap list that reaches providers weeks late sends them after members who already closed. These are worth fixing before you buy something new.
Add it when the measure set changed and your plan did not. The Improving or Maintaining Physical Health and Mental Health measures now carry triple weight, and a new Depression Screening and Follow-Up measure starts in MY 2027. Both depend on primary care, behavioral health, and member experience. If nothing in your current plan touches them, that is your gap.
Your vendors: what to ask before you renew
Vendor decisions are where plans lose the most time. The contract renews, the scope stays the same, and nobody asks whether it worked. Before you renew, ask each vendor for five things:
Member-level results, compared against members who did not get the intervention.
What the contract pays for: activity, completions, or measure movement.
How fast their data reaches your HEDIS and supplemental data process, and how much of it was accepted.
Who inside your plan owns the relationship and reviews the results each month.
Their SLA and KPI results, and any complaints, grievances, or appeals tied to their work.
If a vendor can only report its own activity, it is reporting its work. Your renewal notice is your leverage. After January 1, 2027, most of that leverage is gone, and the vendor is part of your MY 2027 results whether it works or not.
Do not wait on the courts
At least 14 insurers have sued CMS over their 2027 Star Ratings, claiming more than $4.1 billion in lost bonus payments combined. The suits argue that CMS used measures it did not adopt through formal rulemaking. CMS has appealed the first ruling in this wave to a federal appeals court. We take no position on the merits of any of these cases.
Our position is about your strategy. Do not hold it, and do not assume a measure will disappear or change because of a lawsuit. It may not. These cases could run for months or years. Every month you wait is a month of the measurement year you do not get back.
There is a difference between a measure leaving through rulemaking and a measure you hope a court removes. CMS publishes the first on a schedule you can plan around. The second is a bet. More rulemaking is already coming: the CMS proposed rule for contract year 2028 has been under federal review since October 26, 2026.
Litigation can change how a score is calculated. It cannot change whether a member got her colorectal cancer screening, or whether her blood pressure is under control. Do the right thing for the member, and the measures follow. If a measure does get removed, the care still counted for the person who got it.
What to do next
Put every Stars initiative and vendor on one list, by contract, with its cost, owner, and measured result.
Make a keep, cut, fix, or add call on each one before December 31, 2026.
Ask every renewing vendor for member-level results against a comparison group before you sign.
Name an owner and a plan for the Health Outcomes Survey measures and for Depression Screening and Follow-Up in MY 2027.
Build your budget on the published measure set.
Frequently asked questions
When were the 2027 Medicare Star Ratings released? CMS released them on October 8, 2026. About 71% of Medicare Advantage prescription drug plan enrollees are in contracts rated four stars or higher. The enrollment-weighted average overall rating is 3.99, down from 4.01 in 2026.
Which measurement year counts for the 2029 Star Ratings? CMS has said the 2029 Star Ratings will use measurement year 2027, which begins January 1, 2027. The program and vendor decisions plans make now shape that year's results.
Should health plans change their Stars strategy because of the Star Ratings lawsuits? No. At least 14 insurers have sued over their 2027 Star Ratings, and the cases could take months or years to resolve. Plan for the measure set CMS has published, and treat any litigation outcome as upside.
Which Star Ratings measures carry more weight in 2027? The Improving or Maintaining Physical Health and Improving or Maintaining Mental Health measures rose from a weight of one in the 2026 Star Ratings to a weight of three in the 2027 Star Ratings.
Sources
CMS, 2027 Medicare Advantage and Part D Star Ratings fact sheet, October 8, 2026. cms.gov
CMS, "Contract Year 2027 Medicare Advantage and Part D Final Rule" fact sheet, April 2, 2026. cms.gov
Becker's Payer Issues, insurers suing over 2027 Medicare Advantage star ratings, November 16, 2026. beckerspayer.com
RISE, Star Ratings litigation: CMS appeal and where cases stand, August 19, 2026. risehealth.org
Office of Information and Regulatory Affairs, pending review of the CMS Contract Year 2028 Medicare Advantage and Part D proposed rule (CMS-4214). reginfo.gov
About the author
Tina M. Dueringer, BSN, RN, CCM, PCC is CEO and Principal Advisor of Dueringer Advisors, Inc., a clinically led advisory firm for health plans and the companies that serve them. About Tina
Discuss this on LinkedIn: Discussion on the Dueringer Advisors LinkedIn page
Talk with us: Contact Dueringer Advisors