Data differences, measure specifications, and the D-SNP landscape

A dual eligible member is scored by more than one program at the same time. CMS Star Ratings, NCQA, and the state Medicaid agency each use their own measures, data rules, and benchmarks. A plan that runs its D-SNP from one scorecard finds the gaps late, usually when a rating arrives. On December 15, 2026, at the RISE Star Ratings Master Class in Scottsdale, we walk through this and how to approach it.

Why this session, why now

On April 2, 2026, CMS finalized the Contract Year 2027 Medicare Advantage and Part D rule. The rule removes 11 Star Ratings measures and adds Depression Screening and Follow-Up, which begins with the 2029 Star Ratings.

Fewer administrative measures means the remaining clinical and member experience measures carry more of the rating. Those are the measures that depend on complete, accurate data. That makes data capture a ratings problem, and a D-SNP is sometimes where data is hardest to capture.

D-SNP enrollment and state integration requirements keep growing. Many Medicaid plans are standing up their first D-SNP, and many Medicare Advantage plans are expanding into new D-SNP markets. Both groups inherit a quality program built for a different line of business with very different issues.

One member, several scorecards = hot mess

The programs that score a dual eligible member do not share one rulebook:

  • CMS Star Ratings rate the Medicare contract.

  • NCQA rates and accredits the health plan, with its own requirements for Special Needs Plans.

  • The state Medicaid agency picks its own measures and sets its own performance targets.

The same member, the same visit, and the same lab result can count in one program and not in another. Teams that track one set of rates against one set of benchmarks miss this until it's too late.

What we will cover at RISE Stars Masterclass

The session has three parts.

  1. Where specification differences create gaps. We compare the scorecards side by side and show where data capture, reporting, and performance tracking break for dual eligible members.

  2. NCQA accreditation and CMS Stars. We explain what NCQA evaluates for D-SNPs and how its ratings differ from CMS Star Ratings.

  3. What it means to enter or expand in D-SNP. We cover the operating decisions that shape the rating: contract structure, integration level, who owns each part of the score, and how to oversee delegates and vendors.

Delegation gets its own time. Under 42 CFR 422.504(i)(1), the Medicare Advantage organization keeps ultimate responsibility for its CMS contract, whatever it hands to another party. You can delegate the work. You cannot delegate the accountability.

Who should attend

  • Stars and quality leaders with a D-SNP today

  • Medicaid plan leaders launching a D-SNP

  • Medicare Advantage leaders entering or expanding in D-SNP markets

  • Care management, pharmacy, and compliance leaders who share the score

Session details

  • Session: Data Differences, Measure Specifications, and the D-SNP Landscape (Track B)

  • When: Tuesday, December 15, 2026, 11:15 AM to 12:00 PM MST

  • Where: The 17th Annual RISE Star Ratings Master Class, December 14, 2026 to December 16, 2026, Fairmont Scottsdale Princess, Scottsdale, Arizona

  • Speakers: Tina Dueringer, BSN, RN, CCM, PCC, Dueringer Advisors, Inc., and Kailey Collier, Kern Health Plan

  • Register: RISE Star Ratings Master Class registration

  • Agenda: Full schedule

Frequently asked questions

When and where is the D-SNP session at the RISE Star Ratings Master Class?

The session runs Tuesday, December 15, 2026, from 11:15 AM to 12:00 PM MST in Track B. The Master Class takes place December 14, 2026 to December 16, 2026 at the Fairmont Scottsdale Princess in Scottsdale, Arizona.

Why can a D-SNP have strong HEDIS rates and a weak Star Rating?

CMS Star Ratings, NCQA, and state Medicaid programs use different measures, data rules, and benchmarks. A result that counts in one program may not count in another. Plans that track one scorecard miss the difference until ratings post.

Can a health plan delegate responsibility for D-SNP quality performance?

No. A plan can delegate the work, but under 42 CFR 422.504(i)(1) the Medicare Advantage organization keeps ultimate responsibility for meeting the terms of its CMS contract.

Sources

About the author

Tina M. Dueringer, BSN, RN, CCM, PCC, is CEO and Principal Advisor of Dueringer Advisors, Inc.

Register for the RISE Star Ratings Master Class | Discuss this on LinkedIn | Talk with us

Next
Next

Stars strategy is a multi-year plan, not an annual fire drill