Breaking: CMS proposes cutting 19 Star Ratings measures

CMS has proposed cutting 19 measures from the Medicare Advantage Star Ratings, removing the reward factor, and narrowing the improvement hold harmless, starting with measurement year 2028 and the 2030 Star Ratings. In 12 states, a new mandatory model would replace Star Ratings with Diamond Ratings. The proposal is open for public comment.

Much of what Stars and HEDIS teams are working on today could look very different soon.

What CMS just filed

CMS filed the Contract Year 2028 Medicare Advantage and Part D proposed rule (CMS-4214-P2) for public inspection ahead of Federal Register publication on November 25, 2026. The Stars and HEDIS changes start with measurement year 2028 and the 2030 Star Ratings.

19 measures up for removal

  • HEDIS: Breast Cancer Screening, Colorectal Cancer Screening, Diabetes Eye Exam, Kidney Health Evaluation, Osteoporosis Management in Women who had a Fracture, Care for Older Adults (Medication Review and Functional Status Assessment), Transitions of Care, Statin Use in Persons with Diabetes

  • HOS: Monitoring Physical Activity, Reducing the Risk of Falling, Improving Bladder Control

  • CAHPS: Annual Flu Vaccine, Getting Appointments and Care Quickly, Rating of Health Plan, Rating of Drug Plan

  • Part D: Concurrent Use of Opioids and Benzodiazepines, Polypharmacy: Use of Multiple Anticholinergic Medications in Older Adults

  • Depression Screening and Follow-up: added for the 2029 Star Ratings, it would come out after one year

The proposed 2030 set keeps 15 measures: 8 outcome and intermediate outcome measures, 3 patient experience measures, 2 process measures, and the 2 quality improvement measures.

The reward factor and hold harmless change

CMS proposes to remove the reward factor beginning with the 2030 Star Ratings. The improvement hold harmless would only protect contracts rated 4.5 stars and up, instead of 4 stars and up today.

Blood pressure moves to BPC-E

CMS proposes to replace Controlling Blood Pressure with Blood Pressure Control for Patients With Hypertension (BPC-E) starting with measurement year 2029 and the 2031 Star Ratings. BPC-E has a wider denominator and uses electronic clinical data systems (ECDS) reporting. CMS will collect both measures for measurement years 2027 and 2028.

CMS's own simulation

Using 2027 Star Ratings data, CMS projects that about 58% of MA-PD contracts would drop in overall rating, and about 20% of contracts would lose quality bonus payments. CMS scores the Star Ratings changes at $106.96 billion in savings from 2028 through 2037.

Diamond Ratings in 12 states

The rule also proposes ADVaNCE MA, the first mandatory CMS Innovation Center model in Medicare Advantage. Its Diamond Ratings system would replace Star Ratings for model plans.

  • 12 states, chosen by stratified random sampling and named in the final rule

  • Diamond Ratings replace Star Ratings and the 4-star quality bonus threshold for model plans

  • Quality is rated at the parent organization level within each state, in two cohorts: general enrollment contracts and D-SNP-only contracts

  • Payment moves to a continuous scale, so every increment of performance counts, not just crossing 4 stars

  • Measures start out the same as the Star Ratings, but CMS can change them during the model

  • Model plans stay in the Star Ratings for 2029 and 2030. The first Diamond Ratings display in October 2030, and the first Diamond-based payments come in 2032

  • I-SNPs and employer group plans are excluded. State Medicaid directors can opt all D-SNPs out of the model, but only by October 1, 2027

Comment now

Your 2030 Star Ratings get decided in measurement year 2028. That clock starts in 13 months.

This is a proposed rule, not a final one. CMS considers the comments it receives by the deadline before it finalizes anything. If a measure you rely on is on this list, if the hold harmless change hits your contract, or if your state could land in the Diamond model, tell CMS. Bring your data. Health plans, providers, quality leaders, and vendors all can comment.

Comments are due 60 days after filing. Submit them on regulations.gov under docket CMS-2026-3533, file code CMS-4214-P2.

Proposed is not final. Make them hear you.

Frequently asked questions

When would the Star Ratings changes take effect?

The measure removals, the end of the reward factor, and the new hold harmless threshold would apply to measurement year 2028 and the 2030 Star Ratings. BPC-E would replace Controlling Blood Pressure starting with measurement year 2029 and the 2031 Star Ratings.

Which states are in the Diamond Ratings model?

CMS has not named them. CMS proposes to select 12 states through stratified random sampling and will publish the list in the final rule.

Is this final?

No. CMS-4214-P2 is a proposed rule. CMS considers comments received by the deadline before it issues a final rule.

How do I comment?

Submit comments electronically on regulations.gov under docket CMS-2026-3533, file code CMS-4214-P2. Comments are due 60 days after the rule was filed for public inspection.

Sources

About the author: Tina M. Dueringer, BSN, RN, CCM, PCC, is CEO and Principal Advisor of Dueringer Advisors, Inc. About Tina

Discuss this on LinkedIn: Join the conversation

Talk with us: Contact Dueringer Advisors

Next
Next

Data differences, measure specifications, and the D-SNP landscape